Wednesday, January 11, 2017

The Court Responds: The Case for New Zealand





First, my own frustration at the delay to a meaningful resolution to New Zealand's water issues I suspect reflects most people’s outlook. The sooner we shift our mentality towards water as something to revere and respect, rather than drag our feet on piecemeal changes, the better for all. In the current climate of slander and off-the-ball tactics, that we maintain a discussion is something to protect.

Now, to continue in the vernacular Dr. Edmeades presented in a mock court session, let the court respond.

Dr. Edmeades, your impassioned plea to consider the rural economy in water quality legislation of New Zealand is heard. However, you’re misrepresentation of the agricultural sector as victim, belies a dangerous bias in your argument. This industry has had, and continues to have, unquestioned and unrestricted access to New Zealand’s previously abundant and clean water and, as no one can dispute, has made significant profit off this valuable and rare characteristic. To continue this victim dialogue in the face of significant public distress and an immense scientific consensus is irresponsible from a commentator and scientist of your standing in the rural community. You would also do well to caution your colleagues from taunting theNew Zealand public. Boasting that the agriculture sector has become wealthier than the rest of a merely “jealous” New Zealand through the exploitation of this common lifeblood of the country, is contemptible.

The goal to make arguably the most well-known river in New Zealand swimmable and safe to collect food from, is not empty. This river rests within multiple populations which have relied on its food for centuries. If that is meaningless to you, it runs through multiple tourist hot-spots, an industry that is quickly out-pacing your own. The NPS statement you reference as a benchmark, has been set by a government with a self-imposed mandate to double agricultural exports by 2025. The only way such a target could be achieved is through wholesale water quality and quantity decline, and your argument that the Healthy Rivers Plan is too strict if it exceeds this, is misinformed. Your preference to use pathogen “alarm bells” and reactive treatment of polluted water over preventative solutions shows a misunderstanding of the severity of our current water crisis and a disregard for any industry but your own. With over 60% of our rivers unsafe and a notable increase in the frequency of drinking water pollution, your request for a more relaxed approach to mitigation entails that the court asks; where would you draw a line on allowable contamination?

In response to your scientific claims. You argue semantics around the term swimmable effectively to some. As you seem to appreciate, the health of rivers is dependent on multiple factors. Nitrogen and phosphorus cause excessive growth of pest weed species and often toxic algae, which in turn depletes oxygen, killing aquatic life. Nitrogen and phosphorus are no less a swimmability problem than arsenic and cadmium in cigarettes prevent you from smoking. The effect these chemicals have on the health of the whole, Dr. Edmeades, is where the issue lies. In a similar manner, your attempts to divert attention away from catchment scale pollution, towards koi carp and innately “muddy little streams” shows either a willingly poor understanding of hydrology, or an intent to mislead those less knowledgeable of catchment hydrodynamics. Finally, you state that this legislation has arisen from a myopic view of water management. How do you propose that relying on farm consultants which possess an obvious vested interest to provide “off-farm solutions” does not exaggerate the current imbalance in resource management in New Zealand?

To your claims of bankruptcy. I would direct you towards answering the concerns of tourism operators, some of whom are already experiencing such economic constrictions with polluted or dry rivers. I will remind you that although your industry seems unperturbed in using polluted water and running aquifers dry, anyone else is incapable of making a living with such “resources”. I would further request your opinion on the health of rural communities as current practices stand. The epidemic of periodic debt-driven farmer suicide should not be ignored and the insistence in maintaining volume driven farming practices at the mercy of effectively, monopolistic commodity markets, is concerning. It appears morally obvious that your skills and knowledge would be better utilised in assisting farmers in finding ways to produce higher value products, which has been demonstrated can improve profits, reduce the impact on the environment, and reduce the susceptibility of farming communities to variability in global demand for milk powder.


To conclude, social disruption over water in New Zealand is already here Dr. Edmeades. For some time now, this issue has ranked high if not first in New Zealand’s psyche, although continues to come second to economic benefits for industry as you request here. What social and economic cost inaction on this issue has already had, is not well known. New Zealanders are unlikely to shed their agricultural roots and arguably their identity, and despite the best efforts of industry to claim so, no one hates farmers. The science is clear, and that a change in approach is needed, is obvious. The New Zealand public and your peers would greatly benefit from your assistance in seeing this legislation through in an effective way, and from less of your denial and resistance to change.