Saturday, January 28, 2017

Dealing with Challenging Information: A "how to" guide in NZ.



Artist rendering of a potential nitrate troll 

Well, the ugly side of 20th century New Zealand has decided to raise its head out of the sheep dip. Here to remind us all that silly little women should stay out of such manly affairs as farming, Malcolm Lumsden gives us an all too common chance to dive into our ovary-fearing past. Almost as if asked to buy tampons himself, Lumsdens’ offended sensibilities from a woman asking a question let us all know precisely where we stand on gender. Between himself and old boy Morgan, we are not so subtly thrust into 1950s everywhere, reminding a woman of her place – anywhere but questioning a man. Unwilling to take their quarrels to the big boys, these two prefer the publicly belittling young women approach. It must take an insurmountable amount of courage to say “Hey Fonterra, you’re making screeds off us and we're copping a bit of flak, how about you chip in a bit more for the environment?” – attacking young women evidently is much less scary. In picking such targets it’s clear the dusty among us still prefer the mentality that women are feeble minded - the leathery chauvinist Sir Bob is not alone.

Now let’s address the wonderful Donald data in this article, although it is hard to be sure what is meant here, so I’ll paraphrase: “you women send a bunch of gross stuff into the river when you wash your dirty bodies, and do the dishes – which is what women do don’t you know?” Safe to say we all expect farmers wash themselves, their clothes and their dishes also; although maybe Lumsden doesn’t do such uterine jobs as the latter two so perhaps he has a point. Best not wash the ute though, and let’s all give him the benefit of the doubt and assume he doesn’t make any money off the additional 29,400 litres an “average” sized herd consumes each day – because that would be a little rich right?. Although we're left to take his word on it, the "chemicals and nasties" he sez, are rife in people kind of wastewater. Well chemicals sound bad and I doubt his lonely Daisy produces any. I personally think nitrate trolls live under every bridge, I just can’t get a picture of the damned things. One more time, point source discharge is a thing, yes, and living humans will always produce waste, whether we own 2000 cows or not. This wastewater can and is mostly being managed - continuing to advocate that we needn't do anything about the nearly 3 million additional cows we've put on the land in the last 30 years, is truly insane.     

Rampant misogyny and secret information aside for a moment, another strange 1950s gem finds new life among this stellar analysis. Like a good patriot, Lumsden comes at us with the socialist angle, while it sounds like he really wants to say communist – but that would sound crazy. Well ladies and gentlemen, having a desire to see our country's water supply protected, makes you a socialist, and we all know how bad they are. Throw in a couple of “green extremist” terms, a reference to head-commie Dr Joy and pow, if any of us had the guts we would be pulling out these weeds. Although we can be sure most of us don’t sweat too much about the red-tide there are obviously a few who still stand alone in this. And not the good kind of stand-alone against injustice type – more the kind of doomsayer on the corner stand alone. Joined by chief science deniers Rowarth and Edmeades, who it seems are the source of the alternate facts on the state of our water here, I think we can all look forward to more of these antiquated buzz-word scribblings.

This brings us back to this interesting opinion on science. I’d like to ask, again, which science exactly would he prefer not to have to listen to? Let’s say, we find the proverbial cure for cancer - does he want to be notified? Or would he prefer to live in chemotherapeutic bliss? Because of course, it is the same scientific method used to discover things about health, as it is to study the environment. This manifestly rabid anti-science stance that oozes from these articles is presumably only on this issue for the authors – the one that coincidentally costs them money. In this they share a commonality with the scientists they choose to reference and just on a hunch, probably the strongest correlation we could find in this water debate is the one between industry links and denial of scientific consensus. Maybe I’ve used too much jargon already and although Lumsden found call to puff his manly chest after a retail assistant commented on what sounds like an angered attack, these opinions remain unverified – beyond the fringe even.

To make it worse or these folk, this useless, keyboard warrior generation knows nothing of what dairy has given us. If only we could keep going as we always have for the last 54 years. Well in an effort to join in on the reminiscing with another analogy, just imagine if we could still employ slave labour (think pyramids). Think of how cheap we could get things done! No health and safety, no wages, perfect! But, Mr Lumsden, its 2017, and we treat people differently now. I understand that the environment doesn’t have any intrinsic right to perpetuity in your mind and although you should be the first to appreciate it, you seem not to have noticed that few people own just a couple of cute jerseys called Daisy now. That fact alone affects our children’s intrinsic right to healthy resources in perpetuity. A principle we wrote into that ground-breaking RMA document way back when. "But the dairy industry has put 1 billion dollars into remediation", you remind us. Well for an industry that proudly makes $18.1 billion each year from exports alone, I can’t think of a stronger case for an industry participation award in New Zealand. Just think, if Richie scored a try or two, but let through 10-fold more each game, would you still want him as the dairy ambassador? Nah.  


While very reluctantly, government has put a loose leash on industrial farming compared to the golden days, and the ever-promising left decries change will come if only they can get someone to listen, the rest of us are left to manage a hostile clan of nostalgic victim card-players. As these views will always find a talk-show host or two poised to gobble down anything, (rugby) balls and all, that might provide a kickback, I’ve provided a brief flowchart that will hopefully outline this cherished approach to science, women, and the environment that stagnates in our national dialogue. Although many (can I say most yet?) are prepared and willing to change farming practices, for those who wish to allay their fears that change is coming, and for those who’ll never admit anything to those commie-sympathising, hippy, tree-hugging, druggy-loser eco-warrior scientists, feel free to use this template anytime you’re confronted with information that challenges your testicles. You needn’t possess wit or creativity, with just a few key words and tried and true slander techniques, you’ll appear righteous and knowledgeable to anyone in earshot (simply increase the volume to increase earshot).