Here is a draft something I wrote a while ago when I was in the depths of a shitty time. I'd just started (relatively) a PhD and it wasn't working out how I thought it would. I didn't want to write/share anything. I've had some help,I feel more stable, I'll try to return a make this a little more concise.
Fig 1. An attempt to justify
indulgence in adjectives.
It’s been a while since I’ve had
the motivation to write. I've been in a rut of hopelessness for a few months
with a pressing numbness reaching a crescendo in the last couple of weeks: the
clichéd husk. The only feeling I’m able to sense is what seems like
literal the very energy being sucked out as punishment for being awake. Zero motivation even for the things I love,
no focus, everything is bad or could be better, and I’m just mad and insular. I’ve had this feeling before, though less physically
debilitating. I'm doing better, and being cognisant of the rising tide of aware of my focus on the bleakness has helped. Hesitant to call it depression, I feel guilty if
I do for others have it much worse and even though I’m telling myself it doesn’t
matter and it won’t change anything, the best I can do is assess and reflect.
Eight months into starting my
PhD, and almost a year into moving to North America, I’ve hit this low mark
well before I expected I would. I acknowledge many things contribute to this, a lot of which are personal beyond my capacity to discuss here. The most obvious, "low-hanging" contributor is an almost obsessive preoccupation with aspects of the world that make me sad and angry. Being forced to
watching idiots policies instated that systematically defund and destroy science is infuriating and stressful, perhaps more so as a science student looking at my future. I
look at everyone around me and I’m mad people are not more upset. Not more mad
like I am. They are all too focused on being entrepreneurs and having
successful careers. In marketing themselves to future employers who
hold their livelihoods in their omnipotent grasp. Why can’t we all be
miserable and angry together? Why don’t
you want to change things, be part of a better system? Why do I have to pick up other people's trash? Why isn’t my PhD
research being funded? I'm spinning my wheels and I wish it was as simple as the helpful advice of "keep smiling, just focus on something else".
This is less a commentary on actual what I see and feel in people around me, merely and the stress of our collective science experience, and there are :many of
my peers are struggling with the same disappointments. A large chunk of my mental wallowing is devoted to trying to reconcile that the oases of respite from corporate interest I envisioned in science, were was always just
another idealism. Reflecting then on my place in a generation demonised for having it too easy,
I’m also accepting that we are not only financially crippled by this a necessity (let alone choice) to educate ourselves, but that many of us will also be priced out of financial independence by the time we have any earning potential.
That education is mutually one of the most expensive and obligatory employee
traits is most illuminating and feels like powerlessness embodied.
This false bastion of objectivity
and truth, science, seems to exist in actuality as a pit of corporate productivity, politicised
both left and right beyond recognition. Those clammy business hands have again
wrangled the reins and now determine the value of science and through
restricting research, have forced the pursuit of knowledge into another
begging exercise. Financial interest determines how and what we research, and
most importantly how intensely we need to justify our passions, and our right to
not be team players working for the company. and Ssearching for that raw interest and delight I had as a hopeful teenager has become more strained. I’m not trying to put scientists per se, on a moral pedestal and no one should ever expect scientists to be more objective, truthful,
or have it any easier than anyone else. Examples are plentiful of corrupt, data
manipulating scientists out for money, or simply those that have thrown their
critical faculties away to save face amongst backers. I was always aware of
this but I guess I had higher hopes for the job.
Evidently, the reality check about the education industry always loomed as I’ve waited for the real science, devoid
of these inconsistencies to show itself. Full of its high functioning,
ambitious, and critical thinkers, science appears just another vault of
inequality, discrimination, and belittling free-market competitiveness.
I would've thought we there could’ve
had been an annual meeting once a year in the science lair to come up with a plan to
circumvent this circumvention and keep science scientific. Instead it seems we ignored
this contradiction to our oft-trumpeted objectivity, simply to avoid ruffling feathers. The final pin drop, that science doesn’t operate outside the confines
of current social and "return on investment" mentalities as I thought it should, and rather that it is
mangled by the familiar caprice of big money, insecure egos, and personality
politics is the most disheartening and if preventing this bastardisation isn't your priority, you're not doing your job (Geezus). At least this reaffirms that people in
positions of influence have nothing any more figured out than us
bottom feeders, and that motivations, should always be questioned.
Switching to a little more mental reflection, recognising the juxtaposition between where my attention lies and
my desire for an even keel is half the problem. Realising that achieving happiness
as a constant state is a little unrealistic might also help. I’m by no means
the first to comment on this but I certainly have a tendency to view the world in
binary states and the idea that one day I’ll find happiness, exemplifies this.
There is of course no reality possible on this planet where I will be content.
That’s just not how my brain works nor the majority of others, not to mention being
a gross oversimplification of our world. This applies to effectively everything
and expecting that I could dedicate a life of work towards one such binary
state for the world or myself, was always going to fall flat. Still, I
desperately don’t want to be outwardly cynical all my life, even if it does
feel more honest. The courage and tenacity of so many early career scientists and experienced professors in speaking out against a very obvious and moronic assault on science. These give me hope,
and make me less disillusioned, and I appreciate that I write this (and that I can write this) from a position of huge privilege
myself. I sincerely don’t wish to ignore injustices
far greater than those I perceive: this is nonetheless my human experience and
I hope an effort to talk about mental fragility is clear.
I have an appreciation that with the privilege of studying ecological science and the importance of evidence based policy,
our collective situation will forever make me nervous. This nervousness and
anxiety will always tempt me to my melancholyic indulgence, which unchecked, leads me here. The further temptation, to find this feeling of hopelessness-come-indifference liberating of my passion and compassion, I know I must also keep in check. If I can learn to derive enjoyment
from small scale change in the face of such systemic, urgent, and overwhelming problems, I'm sure I'll be closer to fulfillment.
My next step then, is learning to take pleasure in stoking the fires of change and
accepting that there simply is no combination of words and data I alone can
come up with that will save the world today. This acceptance I know is critical
as even having suffered the embarrassing recognition about my beloved science,
I still cannot do anything else.
