Thursday, January 5, 2017

Change is good, Jon


Cartoon by Sharon Murdoch

I’m not a vegan. I try to reduce my animal protein intake, but you needn't light those torches yet. 

If only to counter the tedious rhetoric that passes as newsworthy, I have to respond to the propaganda piece with the byline, “Jon Morgan explains what a vegan New Zealand would look like”. As should be clear to most, one particular group of apologists in New Zealand need not base explanations on facts, or even attempt to strike balance in order to be published.

Morgan begins boldly by plainly patronising one of his young family members in order to make what is for him, a political point. Rather than encourage inquiry in a mind searching for more sustainable and ethical ways to feed humanity, he chooses a public forum to belittle his niece. Besides having the largest conflict of interest on a topic in which he remains illiterate, as any reasonable person would say, I’m glad I’m not his niece.

He continues with the predictable undercurrent of most industry apologists, implying vegans are idiots and unfit parents, unable to understand complex things like growing animals - but he’s able to like some of them nonetheless. I can hear the sighs of relief from vegans nationwide now. The ones he doesn’t like however, are the militant ones, bent on making political statements. Hypocrisy may not be a concept Morgan is familiar with as he types his opinion on a news website, but to pretend that agriculture hasn’t and doesn’t have a firm grip on everything political in New Zealand is embarrassing.

Bluntly he acknowledges that animals being abused is inherent in farming, and that some people might not be okay with it. Like a true science denier, Morgan claims only Greenpeace, those useless hippies, are saying that farming is ruining the water. In reality, for decades, the scientific consensus has been that intensive farming has led to the state our waterways are in now with Greenpeace becoming vocal relatively recently.

Without reference, his article continues in a confused and contradictory fashion. There will be a depression and we won’t have enough dietary iron, we will have more bush and diversify our exports, our physical and mental health will plummet as we worry about our living standards, there will be more rats. Though it should be the responsibility of the publisher to do just a little fact checking, it may fall to the rest of us to bring Mr Morgan up to speed.
Not 
As with the rest of the industry, Morgan seems blind to the change that’s already here. The growth in vegan products should be an obvious opportunity for our primary producers. Despite Morgan’s fretting, the vegetarians and vegans of the world aren’t withered husks chewing on rusty spoons. This growing and healthy population of consumers will simply go elsewhere despite his best attempts to dictate what they eat. Animal production is the leading cause of emissions, water use, and pollution in many countries around the world, and although he may join his colleagues in becoming a fully-fledged climate denier, the reality for the rest of us, and for his niece will be starkly different to the good ol’ days. That our young people are asking these questions is a welcome part of New Zealand’s future. That these are the people chosen to answer their questions, shows the grip our antiquated past has on our future.


The responsibility here ultimately lies with those who dress up such ignorant and unnecessary spittle pieces as news, although so lazy is the search for content to fill news sites, it is unsurprising. To flourish in world that’s drastically different from 1960’s hill-country New Zealand, our first step is to shed this systemic insistence that things needn’t change, because we’ve always done it this way. New Zealand is more than agriculture and to use a more respected scientific analogy, to be told you have cancer, and to continue smoking leaves little room for sympathy from your children.