
Cartoon credit - Garrick Tremain as published in ODT.
We are all truly stunned. Two for-sale scientists in New Zealand pedalling the same pseudoscience have managed to find each other. As livestock do, they've flocked together, maybe hoping to halve the probability of a vicious greeny attack from those lazy townies harping on about clean water.
Water water water, here we go again, but they just can't admit that they've fucked it up for all of us. You could almost be forgiven for commending Dr. Rowarth and Dr. Edmeades for such a partisan approach to defending their milk-at-any-cost ideology. Staking your name to such wild anti-scientific claims as the Waikato is clean and climate change isn't real, must put your scientist job in jeopardy. But you wouldn't be forgiven - remember Dr. Rowarth has been appointed chief scientist of the Environmental Protection Agency for our beautiful country, and Dr. Edmeades sits on cushion of agriculture industry money, under the guise of independence.
Dr. Rowarth has been doing her best to conjure a coherent argument that intensive farming isn't doing nothing wrong. She hasn't quite stepped out of obscurity yet. Her recent leaky bore suggestions alongside recommending chlorination of drinking water (to kill the E. coli and Campylobacter we are pouring in) are confused, floundering around in the scientific mud with "chemtrails" and studio moon landings. That the agricultural industry (from research to machinery) already acknowledges contaminant leaching as the pertinent problem to solve for industrial farming doesn't seem to register. Instead she marches backwards, hoping to cloud the waters more and encourage farmers to ignore the responsibility that comes with making money off New Zealand soil.
Fear not! In his own brown cape comes Dr. Edmeades to the rescue. Another scientist-by-title proclaiming both (oxymoronically), to "abhor pseudoscience" and not believe in anthropogenic climate change. Perhaps without options, Rowarth accepts Edmeades effluent snorkel. You would not be forgiven here, to miss the non-significance of this melding of minds. Not only does Dr. Edmeades deny human induced climate change, he also denies the affect intensive farming has on waterways. Those are two long-established, very separate but related, scientific consensuses. The chances that he is our one saviour right about both, are imperceptible. I'm not sure what Dr. Rowarth's stance on climate change is, but by association alone, there should be a tingling of an alarm bell somewhere about the surety of her assertions.
Edmeades predictable and transparent article defending Rowarth's diversion-based approach to a water pollution debate speaks to the baseless argument they both take. One can only assume his analytical complacency built through experience narrating the industry by-line to a captured agricultural audience resulted in this wooden interpretation of the debate. Without any science to bolster his viewpoint, Edmeades becomes obsessed with highlighting the difference between academic titles of Dr. Mike Joy and Professor Rowarth. Taking hypocrisy to its greatest heights, avoiding any discussion of actual facts, he claims the use of cliché by Dr. Joy is enough to void any argument he may have. Edmeades then does his darnedest to paint his superwoman as the measured scientist we rightly expect. With neither himself nor Rowarth possessing any facts of worth to support their claims however, he is left with only the lame tactic of describing Dr. Joy as an alarmist. Such easy misinformation to publish in a farming column. This dull and boring analysis is the kind we can expect from trumpets like Hosking, not someone using the title scientist to gain an audience.
Without then, a scientific vertebra to this irresponsible and delusional stance, we can only examine what these two are touting as reason to doubt Joy. The tired greeny-alarmist label Edmeades smears Dr. Joy with seems to be based on Joy's use of language. Edmeades, by throwing in the "post-normal science" buzzwords, hopes to reduce Joy's argument to opinion, projecting his own arguments shortcomings. The pitying side to this is that Joy possesses all the facts. It's that simple. Neither Edmeades nor Rowarth possess any to support their proposition that we do nothing and this is obvious in their complete absence of factual analysis. And Joy is not alone. The almost complete majority of publishing scientists agree with Joy's facts, as is the case for climate science (what scientific consensus means). You often need only to examine the motives of the minority to see why they might not agree (boringly obvious in this case).
So why would Joy use any language remotely emotive if he possesses the facts? Well, remember this debate, so bluntly assessed, was not a scientific paper it was a radio broadcast. A communication to general public. Edmeades insinuation that at all times scientists must remain robotic is expected from someone who engineers his own facts. Scientists aren't devoid of emotion or cliché. Science is the most robust way to measure the physical environment around us and scientists are tasked with describing that physical environment. Whether or not you use language accessible to everyone to your audience, doesn't change the facts, and it is those facts that lay clearly on one side. Truth and objectivity epitomise the scientific mentality and especially so, when those facts force you stand up against the flow of money. Towing the company line and conceding your objectivity to those with deep pockets is the most disqualifying attribute of any scientist. As scientists then, in this case, these two are failing you. As salespeople, they have certainly earned their commission however.
Despite the facts, we are continuing to be sold the dream that intensive agriculture can be practised on the scale that it is in New Zealand without consequence. Rowarths and Edmeadess are continuing to live in a growth-only market mind-set applying milk volume as their only measure of success. While they continue to chase this dream, we all live with the consequences of their uninspired and conflicted public discourse responsible for yet more delay in improving how we manage our land.
Maybe in the future we will feel the slightest twinge of pity when these dinosaurs do their best to tempt know-nothing millennials in to buying their river-side properties. When they try their hardest to convince us that we can still swim in the river. That the trout are in there somewhere and the toxic algae is natural. But then again, maybe we won't.