Cartoon credit - Andy
When thinking about the commercial exploitation of a country's resources it's understandable to think of tyrants and unscrupulous acquisitions. We are fortunate enough though, to have a blunt and public example in New Zealand of one of the more insidious ways this happens. The debate over how to manage our water resources continues to rage and follows some remarkably damning pollution events. Events you would expect to quell rhetoric and speculation at least for a moment. Through the use of carefully selected language however, at times simplifying, and others complicating, the New Zealand public is continually misled about the causes of our dying water and is yet to see a preventative response to water pollution from its politicians. There is no lack of data, no reasonable waiting period, no further evidence required that action should be taken - only a craven failure of leadership.
In failing to protect New Zealand waterways, New Zealand's politicians are slowly stealing any hope of a secure future for generations beyond themselves. By simplifying and dismissing what should be detailed discussion encompassing complex policy, Key and his team do their best to confuse and distract the public from becoming meaningfully informed about freshwater policy. At the same time, by complicating and busying stubbornly simple facts, an individuals motivation to become informed and engaged in public discourse rapidly wanes.
One prong of this tactic, involves describing policy objectives and guidelines in simple terms. An unwillingness to put any freshwater protection in place - in fact an intention to reduce freshwater protection to pave the way for industry expansion is coined "progressive gains". An attractive sounding notion repeated at every possible occasion. A higher standard of protection is simply described as "impractical" without explanation and New Zealand waterways are "pretty good" despite all evidence to the contrary. Expecting every waterway to be swimmable is simply "unrealistic", regardless of them being so in the not so distant past. These colloquial terms are fantastic tools to distract people from looking further (aware of the impact an informed public could have on proposed developments) and helps to confirm industry apologists preconceived notions that the industrialisation of farming hasn't had any impact in New Zealand.
In reality, the government has reduced the standard of protection for waterways across a number of parameters. These parameters are complex and span public realms from primary contact with water (swimming), drinking water, the health of wildlife, recreation and tourism. Each affected by different reductions in protection standards. Protection of water is a societal necessity, and when describing water protection, public discussion simply can't be reduced to single words; it is more complicated than that. People can and do understand policy when engaged, but by reducing what should be in-depth debate to catch phrases, the under-informed unwillingly do the governments work by accepting (as they should be able to) at face value that their health must surely be a priority in such a practical approach to policy.
The second prong of this tactic is to complicate what are simple facts and concepts everyone should understand. Our water is polluted. You shouldn't be swimming in over 60% of our rivers. The excrement from the huge numbers of cows we farm has seeped into our aquifers and is poisoning and killing people. Further expansion of dairy and irrigation is reckless. Dams are not good for the environment and irrigation has sucked Canterbury dry. Those are the facts and as an engineer, as we are so frequently reminded, Nick Smith should be familiar with idea that facts aren't negotiable. At every juncture, all efforts are made to make these very simple facts, complicated. Detailed descriptions of how birds are the source of E.coli, and that they are the reason stronger water protection is "impossible". Descriptions of the number of waterways that aren't deep enough to swim in, therefore a swimmable standard is irrelevant. Campylobactor infections directly related to ruminants, become "hard to trace" and further investigation is needed. Key and Smith seem content to legitimise industry intensification and even dam projects by calling claim to evidence in single, industry funded papers. This is while rejecting decades of independent peer reviewed scientific studies outlining the damage and decline of freshwater ecosystems, by stating "more investigation is needed".
The greatest tragedy of this clumsy, sporting like approach to New Zealand's public health, is that New Zealanders have been disconnected from decisions about our own future and unable to prioritise our own individual health over the wealth of a precarious industry. Perhaps rather than hoping our leaders will do the right thing and assuming they have our future in mind, we should learn to assess the evidence ourselves. To become more critical and demand a higher level of respect from our leaders, when they are awarded such a privilege. Unchecked, the abuse of our resource will undoubtedly continue under that ever present guise of progress.
