It is legal. It saves species. There are no other options. Opponents of trophy hunting are attempting to get in the way of the export of trophies to the UK and the conservationist/ecologist community has rallied around the data, missing the point once again.
Our
solution when addressing ethically questionable practices is to shield
ourselves with safety of data and pragmatism. Ethical objections
to trophy hunting are understood by ecologists, and the practice is even morally repugnant for
some. We still manage however, to patronize “well-meaning” but implicitly ill-educated
members of the public, who simply don’t understand the nature of nature, particularly
in a far off place like Africa. If only this were a question of simple population curves.
That this
is clearly an ethical objection to a social practice remains lost on
our scientific community, whenever this inconvenient objection arises. We
endorse a practice limited to the extremely wealthy, presumably mostly western
enthusiasts, of hunting exotic animals in a far-away place and transporting the trophy back home. This simply brings in too much money to really question, and
without these well-intentioned trophy hunters, who knows where the populations
of the quarry would be now? More are killed illegally anyway, so why not let a few rich folks pay to do it? Ethical balance sheet balanced.
Analogies
are blunt, but in most instances we seem able to see the problems in such
concessions in the pursuit of cash. Should we allow a few wealthy individuals
to run regulated dog fighting rings? We might see booms in these communities as
veterinarians, pit cleaners, bite-force researchers and breeders would benefit. Perhaps we allow some level of animal abuse and
mistreatment, so as long enthusiasts pay enough that we see a benefit in the
local community. These crass and exaggerated examples
we generally won’t tolerate; they are self-evidently ethically imbalanced.
Regardless of the benefits to some party, we would refrain from chastising
opponents of these examples, as the ethical losses seem obvious. Even when
culture and finance are at stake, we are proud to proclaim some animal killing
is simply unacceptable, particularly at home (see the recent change on cock-fighting policy in U.S.territories).
We nod to
papers within our own field that address the issues with our rationalisations, though we continue unabated. We rationalise our ethical concession, rather than
engaging ourselves in the social arena in a meaningful way. We choose not to publicly question the fact that our best option at current for African beasts,
is to allow those who can, to pay exorbitant amounts of money to shoot them. They will be interested in preserving the population as well, as
they will want to shoot more in the future. Rationalism
about population dynamics, local politics, and our wider failings to address
the actual issue impacting these
species make us feel better about this stance. We gladly correct the public in
their ethical objections and explain there is no other way - and provide oodles of scientific evidence to tell them so. Simultaneously, we wear our
science communicator hats, commentating on this social issue, communicating
that ethical objection to trophy hunting misses the social context, because of the
population dynamics of trophy worthy species.
We are effortless in this ethical sidestep in places closer to home too. We make
plans for ineffective predator culls: addressing the ultimate cause isn’t
economically palatable. We gratefully take funding from industries that profit
from habitat destruction (see – resource extraction), at our most righteous,
under the premise that we will study the impacts. We have made value judgments
repeatedly as conservationists to stay quieter than we
should about ultimate causes of species loss, while taking the moral high ground criticizing the public for not being concerned in the right ways. We all do this for reputation, for research funding, and for ease. We tell ourselves we alone are justified in these ethical judgments,
as we know the truth: the public can’t be, they don’t understand science and the
funding of it. Celebrity backing of anything is generally hard to swallow, but we confuse our understanding of science with ethical authority and choose to
maintain this dichotomy between ourselves the public. Our preference however, to covet data and population dynamics and model nit-picking should we not have to make unattractive noise
about agriculture, forestry, oil and gas etc, plainly reminds us of our own ethical principles.
In spite of ourselves, another opportunity
for self-reflection on the messages we communicate to the public, on our own
ethical standing, and our own well-meaning but archaic approach to public
engagement, is lost. Why are we unable to do both? Provide the numbers, and
have the human conversation about the consequences. Rally less around the data,
that is our unchanging base, and focus more on our lethargic policy, on our immovable
industries, and address the ultimate mechanisms that are killing our animals.
No one is objecting to saving populations of these animals - they are objecting trophy hunting in a time when we haven't been able to halt the destruction of habitat. To our collective failing to address climate change. They are objecting to endorsing a practice where some wealthy individuals are still able to shoot endangered species for pure enjoyment. The justification that this is the easiest way to maximize population stability should be as difficult to sell as wolf culls, and we all should roll over a little less easily. Whether we are willing to promote a model of a few preserves in a land not our own, saved for the wealthy to come and vacation, and be led to a proud looking lion to shoot, is a conversation we should all have.
![]() |
| 40 years of Sustainable forestry in the Canadian foothills. |
No one is objecting to saving populations of these animals - they are objecting trophy hunting in a time when we haven't been able to halt the destruction of habitat. To our collective failing to address climate change. They are objecting to endorsing a practice where some wealthy individuals are still able to shoot endangered species for pure enjoyment. The justification that this is the easiest way to maximize population stability should be as difficult to sell as wolf culls, and we all should roll over a little less easily. Whether we are willing to promote a model of a few preserves in a land not our own, saved for the wealthy to come and vacation, and be led to a proud looking lion to shoot, is a conversation we should all have.
![]() |
| Our best shot at saving the species. |
Stating that this any means approach results in a greater ethical good, doesn't make it so, and ecology's record of ethical justification is weak at best. Accusing concerned people of diverting attention from the real issues of habitat loss and climate change only displays our myopia. We are not the intelligent few who can process ethical problems with trophy hunting of endangered populations AND be aware of the impacts of habitat loss and climate change. People, even hunters, can understand both, and should be able to rely on their scientists to provide the numbers. Our understanding of population dynamics and our experience in local politics allows us to provide information in the conversation, but doesn't give us priority in the ethical questions we all need to grapple with.


